Independent directors not warranted for super funds

12 August 2014
| By Malavika Santhebennur |
image
image
expand image

Mandating independent directors on not-for-profit industry superannuation funds does not guarantee improved fund performance and could hinder retirement incomes, a centre-left think tank believes.

The McKell Institute issued a new report titled ‘The Success of Representative Governance on Superannuation Boards', saying super funds with representatives from employer and employee bodies on their board of directors have outdone for-profit appointed trustee competitors on performance.

"The Federal Government should hold off on mandating reform in this area without providing strong evidence in favour of such a change," the McKell Institute's executive director Sam Crosby said.

"The trillions of dollars of Australians' retirement savings are far too important to our future to jeopardise with ideological dogma."

After the Institute investigated 25 years' worth of statistical evidence, empirical data and existing research, Crosby asked "when a system is working better than the alternative, why tamper with it?"

"There is abundant room for reform across our superannuation sector, but it would seem misguided in the extreme for the federal government to fixate of ‘fixing' one of the areas that is actually delivering," he said.

Industry Super Australia chair Peter Collins said he is not surprised the representative governance model has been effective for Australian retirees.

"ISA has always argued that pragmatism and evidence should trump pre-conceived ideological positions and this report adds a thorough and important body of evidence to the debate," he said.

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest developments in Super Review! Anytime, Anywhere!

Grant Banner

From my perspective, 40- 50% of people are likely going to be deeply unhappy about how long they actually live. ...

11 months ago
Kevin Gorman

Super director remuneration ...

11 months 1 week ago
Anthony Asher

No doubt true, but most of it is still because over 45’s have been upgrading their houses with 30 year mortgages. Money ...

11 months 1 week ago

Jim Chalmers has defended changes to the Future Fund’s mandate, referring to himself as a “big supporter” of the sovereign wealth fund, amid fierce opposition from the Co...

1 day 6 hours ago

Demand from institutional investors was the main driver of growth in Australia’s responsible investment (RI) market in 2023, as the industry continued to gain momentum....

1 day 6 hours ago

In a new review of the country’s largest fund, a research house says it’s well placed to deliver attractive returns despite challenges....

1 day 7 hours ago