APRA accused of inappropriate heatmap comparisons

12 December 2019
| By Mike |
image
image
expand image

The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) has fallen into the trap of not comparing like for like when it produced its superannuation fund heatmaps.

What is more it had not looked at a core outcome – whether funds had achieved their investment return objective.

NSW-based energy industry superannuation fund, EISS Super chief executive, Alexander Hutchison said that while his fund welcomed APRA’s efforts to compare MySuper funds, it was clear that the methodology required further development before the heatmaps could be relied upon.

“Chief among EISS’ concerns is that APRA’s use of data did not present an apples and apples comparison of its MySuper product,” he said.

“Our concerns with respect to the publication of the APRA heatmap, that it is essentially a league table, have been realised. We are being compared to other MySuper funds that have a significantly larger exposure to growth assets, so it is not an apples and apples comparison,” Hutchison said.

He said EISS was surprised that the heatmaps didn’t look at whether funds achieved their investment return objective, essentially their promise to members.

“We exceeded our investment target for our MySuper product over three, five, seven and 10 years but it seems APRA wasn’t concerned whether funds were true-to-label and resorted to comparing investment performance against a complex cluster of generic benchmarks,” Hutchison said.

“We believe a better measure of investment performance is to consider actual risk adjusted returns taking into consideration the volatility of the MySuper option. We’re a lower risk, lower cost fund and have been compared with funds that take greater risk and should therefore be expected to deliver higher returns,” he said.

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest developments in Super Review! Anytime, Anywhere!

Grant Banner

From my perspective, 40- 50% of people are likely going to be deeply unhappy about how long they actually live. ...

10 months 1 week ago
Kevin Gorman

Super director remuneration ...

10 months 2 weeks ago
Anthony Asher

No doubt true, but most of it is still because over 45’s have been upgrading their houses with 30 year mortgages. Money ...

10 months 2 weeks ago

The profit-to-member super funds are officially operating as a merged entity, set to serve over half a million members. ...

1 day 9 hours ago

Super Review announced 21 winners at the annual Super Fund of the Year Awards, including the recipient of the prestigious Fund of the Year Award....

2 days ago

APRA data shows the CFMEU accounted for 28 per cent of super fund industrial contributions, with the shadow treasurer calling for a prompt investigation into the payments...

3 days 4 hours ago