While the Productivity Commission (PC) has taken a negative view of lifecycle superannuation products, they should not be dismissed out of hand, according to actuarial research house, Rice Warner.
In an analysis published this week, Rice Warner has maintained that not all lifecylcle products are created equal and that the results of the PC’s modelling are a symptom of design, not an encumbrance of the concept.
It said that, on this basis, it did not believe the PC’s findings should be allowed to result in a ban on lifecycle investments.
“Arguably, a lifecycle product with a full allocation to growth in the formative years, de-risking to the ‘more appropriate’ balanced fund supported by the PC ten years out from retirement will produce superior results, with only a marginal increase in risk for the member,” the Rice Warner analysis argued.
“Alternatively, members could move money into a cash account for any lump sum required at retirement and the first year’s pension payments,” it said. “This will allow them to keep high levels of growth assets as they will not need to draw down on the main account, so they are immunised against a market shock at the time of retirement.”
The Rice Warner analysis suggested that technology, particularly improvements in administration and member services, were driving a trend towards smarter, more personalised defaults and that some funds were already providing or considering lifecycle products that varied with balance and age.
“Access to more data will allow funds to segment membership into homogenous groups using age, gender and account balance as relevant factors,” it said.
Future Group is set to take on nearly $1 billion in funds under management (FUM) and welcome more than 100,000 new members following two significant successor fund transfers.
Insignia’s Master Trust business suffered a 1.9 per cent dip in FUA in the third quarter, amid total net outflows of $1.8 billion.
While the Liberal senator has accused super funds of locking everyday Australians out of the housing market, industry advocates say the Coalition’s policy would only push home ownership further out of reach.
Australia’s largest superannuation fund has confirmed all members who had funds stolen during the recent cyber fraud crime have been reimbursed.
would have been nice to get a summary of what the PC had a problem with to give some context. Is this written on the expectation everyone has read the PC mike?