Brand strength and niche positioning will be deciding factors in the survival of small to medium superannuation funds as the industry continues to consolidate chief executive of Non-Government Schools (NGS) Super Anthony Rodwell-Ball said.
According to Rodwell-Ball, superannuation funds need to respect the brand value they bring and the feel they create for their members.
"Our board sees no value in diluting the strong niche position that we've got, so we would really want to maintain that niche position in order to survive," he said.
Having hundreds of thousands of members with no common linkage would make it hard to maintain high levels of service and member engagement, he said.
The fund's target market was the professional community-focused sector, with education at the centre making up approximately 60-65 per cent and the remainder in credit unions, mutuals and some aged, health and child care from the UC Super merger in March, according to Rodwell-Ball.
Rodwell-Ball personally dealt with complaints arising from documents with his name on it and has about three dozen members that contact him directly with their queries.
"While everyone's screaming scale and arguing for the benefits of scale, you still have to be able to maintain as personal a relationship with the member as you can, and that's hard when you get up to the many hundreds of thousands of members," he said.
But NGS Super has not ruled out any possible mergers, Rodwell-Ball said.
"As long as the fit was right and we don't become an all-things to all-people multi-employer multi-industry fund … there are some clear and obvious potential marriages in the industry generally. There are a number of sectors where you could see key consolidation - I think education is one of those," he said.
He said competition between superannuation funds was good because it made the industry perform better.
The Super Members Council (SMC) has called for a removal of the “outdated” 30-hour threshold for workers under 18 to guarantee all young Australian workers receive a super start to work.
SuperRatings has shared the median estimated return for balanced superannuation funds for the calendar year 2024.
The $90 billion fund delivered double-digit returns in its flagship Growth option last year and remains optimistic for 2025.
A strategic overweight to US and global equities along with an increased exposure to private debt and diversified credit has seen AMP deliver a return of more than 15 per cent for its three largest Lifestage cohorts in 2024.