POWERED BY MOMENTUM MEDIA
Super performance test will promote mediocrity
The Budget measure that will block underperforming superannuation funds from taking new members is draconian, overly simplistic, and will promote index relative mediocrity, according to JANA.
JANA principal consultant, Matthew Griffith, said the move would reduce industry innovation and reduce the appetite for trustees to be different.
The approach, he said, was heavy-handed, interventionist, and ignored natural market forces and regulatory changes which had in the past resulted in heightened competition, consolidation, and pressure to maintain strong member outcomes.
“The ink is barely dry on recent regulatory innovations that are focused on member outcomes, creating heightened uncertainty with respect to retirement policy stability for members and the industry,” Griffith said.
“Further, this proposed change will potentially drive the market towards an oligopoly structure made up of ‘index huggers’ and mean more mediocre results for members.”
Griffith noted that the test only assessed funds on one criteria, the constant tinkering of super rules undermined confidence in the system and provided challenges for retirees attempting to plan for their retirement over long time horizons, and that this would prompt more extreme progression towards industry consolidation.
“We fear that the drive to be within 0.50% of an index benchmark will result in an ‘averageness’ mindset that might blunt enthusiasm for adopting points of difference which may be truly beneficial to members over the longer term,” he said.
Recommended for you
Jim Chalmers has defended changes to the Future Fund’s mandate, referring to himself as a “big supporter” of the sovereign wealth fund, amid fierce opposition from the Coalition, which has pledged to reverse any changes if it wins next year’s election.
In a new review of the country’s largest fund, a research house says it’s well placed to deliver attractive returns despite challenges.
Chant West analysis suggests super could be well placed to deliver a double-digit result by the end of the calendar year.
Specific valuation decisions made by the $88 billion fund at the beginning of the pandemic were “not adequate for the deteriorating market conditions”, according to the prudential regulator.
TOP PERFORMING FUNDS
ACS FIXED INT - AUSTRALIA/GLOBAL BOND
Fund name
3y(%)pa
1
Spire Oaktree Opportunities XI Second Close
61.07 3 y p.a(%)
2
Spire Oaktree Opportunities XI First Close USD
59.21 3 y p.a(%)
3
DomaCom Lot 21 Chellaston Road Munno Para West SA 5115 Australia
31.56 3 y p.a(%)
4
Fidante Credit Suisse Global Private Equity
31.06 3 y p.a(%)
5
DomaCom 4/27 Crombie Avenue Bundall QLD 4217 Australia
26.81 3 y p.a(%)
